Welfare effects of capacity constraints at Schiphol Airport - a new modelto forecast air demand.

Author(s)
Kouwenhoven, M. Kroes, E. & Veldhuis, J.
Year
Abstract

Dutch government policy allows the continuing growth of air traffic within strict safety and environmental limits. In order to assess the impacts of new policies on the development of Schiphol airport, the Ministry of Transport, Public Works and Water Management required a new model to forecastdemand for air travel under a wide range of scenarios. Historically air traffic forecasts have been made by extrapolating observed patterns of growth. However, in recent years new dynamics and constraints have entered thesystem. The dramatically increased competition between airports, airlinesand alliances on the one hand, and serious airport capacity issues on theother, has made extrapolations of historic demand no longer adequate. Airport demand forecasts now need to focus heavily on the many competitive elements and on the physical and environmental constraints in addition to standard growth scenarios. In our paper we describe a comprehensive and pragmatic air demand model system that was developed for the Ministry of Transport. The "Airport Network and Catchment area Competition Model" (ACCM), provides forecasts of future air passenger volumes, air freight volumes andaircraft movements. Of particular interest is the way it takes account ofchoices of air passengers among competing departure and hub airports in North-West Europe. The model uses a nested logit structure to represent choices of air passengers among alternative departure airports, transport modes to the airport, airlines (major alliances versus lowcost), air routes (direct versus transfer), and main modes of transport (for intra-Europe trips: car, train, airplane). Passenger forecasts for future years are obtained by taking an observed base year origin-destination matrix, and applyingmarket growth factors and market share shift factors. These last factors express the increase (or decline) in relative attractiveness of the airports and airlines due to anticipated changes in air networks and landside-accessibility. In most scenarios a substantial growth of air traffic towards2020 is predicted. The resulting numbers of aircraft movements often exceed the current runway capacity. Furthermore, the amount of noise generatedby the aircrafts exceeds existing legal boundaries. In order to model theconstraints the model first converts the passenger and freight demand into aircraft movements. Then a shadow price mechanism is applied to adapt both the demand and the movements until they fit the capacity constraints. The aircraft movements submodel distinguishes three dimensions: size of theaircraft (nine classes), technological status of the aircraft (five classes) and moment of departure/arrival (four periods per day), resulting in 180 possible combinations. We have used observed distributions and foreseeable trends to predict the future distributions over these 180 combinations. An estimate of the total number of movements (per year and per period ofthe day) and the total environmental burden (i.e. the amount of noise generated by the departing and arriving aircrafts) can therefore be calculated. If these totals exceed either the physical capacity or the legal environmental noise limit, an iterative procedure is started. Each iteration increases the airfares with a scarcity charge, so that demand is reduced and airlines that fly with larger aircrafts and/or from airports with less severe capacity constraints are favoured. In parallel, incentives for the airlines stimulate the use of larger and more modern (i.e. less noisy) aircrafts. This iterative procedure is repeated until the demand fits the capacity. The resulting tool is capable of modelling a wide range of scenarios, both economic scenarios and airport and airline policies. This includes the introduction of air charges per passenger, per aircraft movement, or perunit of noise generated. In addition, welfare effects, i.e. the changes in consumer surplus relative to a base scenario, are calculated. This enables broad policy assessments in which the optimisation of welfare is taken into account. The tool is currently being used to assess a wide range of policies by the Minister. It is expected that the Dutch government will decide on possible new policies for development of Schiphol airport in April 2006. Though this model was primarily developed for Schiphol airport, the concept of the model is generic and can be applied to other airports and other countries as well. For the covering abstract see ITRD E135582.

Request publication

2 + 2 =
Solve this simple math problem and enter the result. E.g. for 1+3, enter 4.

Publication

Library number
C 46381 (In: C 46251 [electronic version only]) /10 / ITRD E135928
Source

In: Proceedings of the European Transport Conference ETC, Strasbourg, France, 18-20 September 2006, 13 p.

Our collection

This publication is one of our other publications, and part of our extensive collection of road safety literature, that also includes the SWOV publications.